Hydrogen Colour Theory

While hydrogen itself can overcome conventional fossil energy carriers in terms of their carbon footprint, the amount highly depends on how hydrogen is produced. At the moment, mainly "grey" hydrogen is accessable, while manufacturers are working on continously increasing the share of "green" hydrogen. What these colours indicate and how the production processes differ, will be explained in this article.

Different types of hydrogen exist based on the production process

The resulting energy friendlyness of the produced hydrogen depends on the way it was produced, which again highly depends on the primary energy carrier used and the resulting by-products. In general, nine different types of hydrogen exist through these differences, which are mapped in Figure 1.


Figure 1: The different hydrogen "colours" | Grafic: IKEM, Fuel Cell Compass


More than 90 % of the currently produced hydrogen is separated from fossil energy carriers (e.g. Coal, Lignite, Natural gas). The conversion happens through thermal procedures, in which the by-products CO and CO2 occur. The common types are the gasification, the steam reforming, the partial oxidation and the autothermal reforming. The differ based on the form of oxidising agent and happen at high temperatures (700-1,500°C).


If these conversion stages are combined with a Carbon Capture Storage (CCS) or Carbon Capture Usage (CCU), the resulting hydrogen is known as "blue" hydrogen, as it has a smaller carbon footprint. By applying CCS, the CO2 is stored in geological structures, like abandoned gas and oilfields. The aim is that storing the CO2 in the ground under high pressure will lead to the formation of solid organic carbon compounds again after a long period of time. Within the framework of CCU, the CO2 is reused in synthetic fuels.


Another form of separating hydrogen from fossil gas is the methane pyrolyis, which results in turquoise hydrogen. Hereby, the reaction is done without an oxidant and under high temperatures. As a result, the separated carbon is solid and can be stored in the form of bricks in old mine tunnels. Another preliminary for turquoise hydrogen is, that the used heat energy in the process is generated by emission-free energy sources.


"White" hydrogen deschribes natural reservoirs of hydrogen. Just recently, big reservoirs have been found in Europe, especially in northern Spain. Africa also has rock formations, in which the hydrogen has manifested itself. The extraction method however would be similar to the fracking of fossil fuels and is therefore no less controversial.


Separating hydrogen from biomass is another path, which results in "orange" hydrogen. As bioenergy is based on organic materials, this source is limited. Usually, waste and residues from agriculture and forestry are used, which do not allow for scalable mass production. Biomass can be gasified directly or first converted into secondary energy sources. This takes place, for example, via anaerobic fermentation (biogas and biomethane) or alcoholic fermentation (bioethanol).


The last but not least method for gaining hydrogen is via the water electrolysis. By using electricity, water can be splitted into oxygen and hydrogen. Hereby, the origin of the electricity determines the colour of the hydrogen. In case of using nuclear energy, the resulting hydrogen is known as "red" or rarer "pink" hydrogen. In case of using renewables energies, the separated hydrogen can be named as "green". Producing as much green hydrogen as possible is the aim of producers and customers, though, not enough capacities have been build up till now.


Source

Pauline Horng, Michael Kalis, Sabrina Heinecke, Jannis Glahe, Odile Stabon: Wasserstoff-Farbenlehre: Rechtwissenschaftliche und rechtspolitische Kurzstudie (December 2020)

Jörg Adolf, Christoph Balzer, Jürgen Louis, Uwe Schabla, Manfred Fischedick, Karin Arnold, Andreas Pastowski, Dietmar Schüwer: Shell Hydrogen Study: Energy of the Future? (March 2017)

Newsletter

Hier informieren wir regelmäßig über alle wichtigen Entwicklungen im Bereich des Wasserstoffs, der Brennstoffzelle und des Elektrolyseurs.

Downloads

Hier informieren wir regelmäßig über alle wichtigen Entwicklungen im Bereich des Wasserstoffs, der Brennstoffzelle und des Elektrolyseurs.

Whitepaper: In-line Viscosity Measurement

Download a white paper on innovative solutions in the areas of real-time process monitoring and quality assurance